I’ve read on ITT forums that new style foe maemo.org is ready to be criticised by the community and is looking for feedback. As I’m a web-designer aswell, I thought that my feedback would be good advice for maemo.org guys. But I’d like to mention that I’m not the ultimate truth of any kind so it’s just my humble opinion.
So, here are 8 various mistakes in maemo.org fresh style from my point of view.
1. Brain Attack.
The most significant mistake is the choice of the style and the way of giving information to the user. Let’s look at the example of the way that our brain is watching the page:
As you can see, main page is not giving user the information, it’s bombing it. User is totally confused bout what he must do next. Those “hot” and “fresh” blocks are good idea, to bring software to the front but now main page looks like some loud market where every trader is shouting as loud as he can. “Check it out! It’s hot!” “And this is new!” “Get involved right now!” “Or maybe you need some help?! I have one!” “AR-ES-ES!!!”. Mostly that happened because of selecting orange color as the main. It’s too loud and pressing color to put it everywhere, it confuses user. Ok, let’s move on.
2. Text Chaos.
If you’ll count text-styles on one screen, you’ll go mad cause there are seven different font styles on one 800×480 screen. if you want to design some serious portal for serious people – make this number look like 3 or 4 max.
3. The White Stripes.
This is sort of styling mistake, cause <hr> is already used for dividing news, you can’t use it in the bullet list (and it’s totally unnecesary same time, bullet list is 100% readable without any additional dividers)
4. Lost “Search” Word.
5. Graphic Mistake #1.
6. Graphic mistake #2.
7. Unclickable Titles.
This bug is mostly annoying for common maemo.org users cause personaly I got used to click titles and I don’t see any real reason to remove that functionality.
Why not just make it separate block, without that graphical noise that does nothing?
So thats all for now. Many of you would ask “Oh yeah smarty pants? Do something better!” and in my next post I’ll try to come up with something for you :)
Good luck maemo.org team, most of mistakes, described in this post are easily fixable so cheer up!